Can AI Replace Your Financial Adviser? Here's Why We Say No

AI, Wealth Management and Trust: Could Machines Really Replace Human Advisers?
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is already transforming how we live, work, and invest. But as tools like ChatGPT gain popularity, some are starting to ask: do we still need a financial adviser?
At Poole Advisory, our answer is simple: yes. Absolutely.
We see AI as a useful tool, but not a replacement for advice rooted in personal connection, real-world context, and trust.
What AI Is Getting Right
There’s no denying that AI has potential in the wealth space. At its best, it can:
🔹 Analyse vast datasets in seconds
🔹 Spot patterns faster than a human brain ever could
🔹 Generate insights, summaries, and forecasts on the fly
🔹 Provide around-the-clock accessibility
These features make it a great assistant for research, modelling, and even basic portfolio allocation.
Some global firms are already building robo-advice platforms that harness AI to provide basic financial guidance. In a world where financial literacy remains low for many, that could help democratise access.

But There’s a Catch: Trust
According to the World Economic Forum, one of the biggest barriers to AI in financial services is trust. And it’s not hard to see why.
Financial decisions are deeply personal. They’re about more than numbers, they’re about your lifestyle, your family, your future. That requires emotional intelligence, empathy, and sound judgment. Traits that AI, for all its cleverness, just doesn’t have.
People want to feel heard. They want to ask the “silly” questions, share their worries, or talk through goals that go beyond spreadsheets. That kind of support can’t be replicated by code – no matter how sophisticated.
Advice Isn’t One-Size-Fits-All
AI might be able to identify trends and “optimal” strategies, but it can’t consider:
🔹 Your family circumstances
🔹 Business pressures
🔹 Changing tax rules
🔹 Emotional responses to market movements
🔹 The long-term trade-offs between today’s wants and tomorrow’s needs
At Poole Advisory, we tailor every plan to the individual. We don’t just crunch numbers, we consider the life behind them. We want to know your “why” so we can allow you to live a life of prosperity.
Technology + Advice = A Smarter Future
To be clear, we’re not anti-AI. In fact, we use smart tools behind the scenes to enhance our service, whether that’s for data analysis, modelling scenarios, or helping you understand your options more clearly.
But technology should support advice, not replace it.
A well-trained adviser brings strategy and accountability to the table. AI can’t stop you from panic-selling during a market downturn. It won’t challenge your assumptions or help you adjust your plan when life throws a curveball.
Only a human can do that.
The Bottom Line
AI is exciting, and it has a place in modern financial advice. But it’s not a substitute for trusted, values-driven, relationship-based advice.
At Poole Advisory, we believe that the future of wealth management lies in the blend: smart technology and even smarter human support.
If you’re ready to make financial decisions with confidence, not just convenience, then we’re here to help.
Compliance Disclaimer:
This information contains general advice only, that is, advice which does not take into account your needs, objectives, or financial situation. You need to consider the appropriateness of that general advice in light of your personal circumstances before acting on the advice. You should obtain and consider the Product Disclosure Statement for any product discussed before making a decision to acquire that product. You should obtain financial or credit advice that addresses your specific needs and situation before making investment or borrowing decisions. Taxation information is based on our interpretation of the relevant laws as at 1 July 2018. While every care has been taken in the preparation of this information, Prosperitas Partners Pty Ltd does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information. The case studies are hypothetical, for illustration purposes only and are not based on actual returns.
Poole Advisory Pty Ltd ABN 15 642 040 604 is a Corporate Authorised Representative (No. 001282603) of Prosperitas Partners Pty Ltd ABN 30 662 654 453 AFSL 544 917
Get in touch
Learn more
Related Articles

Understanding the Division 296 Super Tax: What It Means If You Have Over $3 Million in Super
From today, 1 July 2025, high superannuation balances may face a new tax under proposed legislation known as Division 296. While the measure is still making its way through Parliament, it’s expected to pass and for those with significant superannuation savings, now is the time to understand how it works and what it could mean for your retirement strategy.

Can AI Replace Your Financial Adviser? Here’s Why We Say No
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is already transforming how we live, work, and invest. But as tools like ChatGPT gain popularity, some are starting to ask: do we still need a financial adviser?

Key Financial Changes Coming on 1 July 2025 for Investors
As the financial year closes, several changes on 1 July 2025 could affect your investment and retirement strategy. Staying ahead of these updates can help you make smarter decisions in the new financial year.
Learn more
Related Articles

Understanding the Division 296 Super Tax: What It Means If You Have Over $3 Million in Super
From today, 1 July 2025, high superannuation balances may face a new tax under proposed legislation known as Division 296. While the measure is still making its way through Parliament, it’s expected to pass and for those with significant superannuation savings, now is the time to understand how it works and what it could mean for your retirement strategy.

Can AI Replace Your Financial Adviser? Here’s Why We Say No
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is already transforming how we live, work, and invest. But as tools like ChatGPT gain popularity, some are starting to ask: do we still need a financial adviser?